Liability Insurance - Occurrence V's Claims Made Wordings ...

For an occurrence wording then, the emphasis when determining whether or not the policy will respond is on when the event that led to the claim occurred, whereas with claims made wordings the emphasis is on when the claim for legal liability was made against the insured.

However, extremely important in relation to claims made policies is the fact that when the event that led to the claim for liability actually occurred is also critical to the decision as to whether the policy will respond.  A claims made policy will contain a "Retroactive Date".  The policy shall only provide cover in respect of events that give rise to the liability occurring after the Retroactive Date specified in the policy.  It is possible that a policy will provide Unlimited Retroactive Cover, which means that the policy will respond irrespective of when the event that leads to the liability occurs.  The Retroactive Date is obviously critical.

Therefore, for a claims made policy wording to respond, the alleged breach that has resulted in the claim, must have occurred after the Retroactive Date stated in the policy schedule, and the pending claim must be made against the insured and reported to the insurer during the period of cover.

 

Page  2

previous pagenext pagehome

So what does this mean to the policyholder?  It means that you must be most particular as to the type of wording that applies to your policy, and if it is a claims made wording you must be most particular that the retroactive date is appropriate to your requirements.  This is extremely important when you are changing insurers, and especially when claims made wordings are involved.  Continuity of cover is essential because any periods of lapse in cover will place the client in a position of being self-insured.

Consider a hypothetical example.  You have a Professional Indemnity policy that is a claims made wording (as they usually are) and decide to change insurers when the policy is due for renewal on 1st July 2001.  The Retroactive Date on your new policy is the same as the commencement of the cover, namely 1st July 2001.  The policy is renewed each year, and then in 2003 you receive advice of legal action claiming a wrongful act by one your coaches that goes back to 2000.  You report this to your insurer, to be told that whilst the action against you is being taken during the period of cover the alleged wrongful act is prior to the Retroactive Date of your policy and therefore the policy will not respond.  In a panic you go back to your previous insurer, to be told that whilst the alleged wrongful act was during the period of cover of their insurance policy, the date of the action against you is outside the period of their policy and therefore the policy will not respond.  Strike three - you're out.

 

      ....Continued page 3